Incarnate by Jodi Meadows
Release Date: January 31, 2012
Author Info: Website | Twitter | Facebook
Publisher: Katherine Tegen Books
Age Group: Young Adult
Shelfability: Acquire/Borrow
Pages: 384
Format: Advance Reader Copy
Source: Publisher
Interest: Debut Author
Challenge: 2012 Debut Author Challenge
Buy the Book: Amazon
New soul
Ana is new. For thousands of years in Range, a million souls have been reincarnated over and over, keeping their memories and experiences from previous lifetimes. When Ana was born, another soul vanished, and no one knows why.
No soul
Even Ana’s own mother thinks she’s a nosoul, an omen of worse things to come, and has kept her away from society. To escape her seclusion and learn whether she’ll be reincarnated, Ana travels to the city of Heart, but its citizens are afraid of what her presence means. When dragons and sylph attack the city, is Ana to blame?
Heart
Sam believes Ana’s new soul is good and worthwhile. When he stands up for her, their relationship blooms. But can he love someone who may live only once, and will Ana’s enemies–human and creature alike–let them be together? Ana needs to uncover the mistake that gave her someone else’s life, but will her quest threaten the peace of Heart and destroy the promise of reincarnation for all?
It’s been several weeks since I’ve turned the last few pages of Incarnate and I’m still not 100% sure with how I feel about it. Somedays I love it, some days I don’t. It’s rather unsettling actually. Usually I have such strong emotions one way or another. Perhaps my indecision is a reflection of the complexity of the book itself?
There are three things that I loved about this novel. The world, Ana, and the writing. (More specifically the world-building.) I wanted to know who and what Ana was, but the thing that kept me engrossed the most was the world. I wanted to discover all it had to offer. It’s secrets, if you will. And although Ana discovers several of them, I can’t help but feel that it’s only the tip of the iceberg.
I enjoyed the relationship between Ana and Sam, yet at the same time I found it to be unnerving. I simply wanted to picture Sam as a teen, but we are constantly reminded that he has had several lives, several forms and several loves. Is Ana only appealing because she is different… A new soul?
The ending was also rather abrupt. The intensity builds and builds, perhaps I was just expecting too much. I’m definitely interested in revisiting this world and these characters. I feel as though the story has only just begun.

Dare You To
Level 2
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Sindre E
Twitter: Repitsu
Really good review! I ordered this book last week and can’t wait to read it myself. =) I was wondering if you’ve read books by any Norwegian or Swedish authors? You should definitely check out Stieg Larson (Swedish, The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo) & Jo Nesbø (Norway, The Redbreast, Nemesis, etc.) Hope you could check them out =3
~Sindre E
Sindre E recently posted..It’s On Time . . . Twilighters & Book Lovers . . . Hopefully Givaway Time!
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Sarah
Twitter: Sarahbotbonkers
I have the same feelings with this book! I can’t tell much if I really loved it or not. But the writing was good so I gave it a fairly good review. Also, Sam has the same effect on me. Knowing he has been many forms before (especially him being a girl) just didn’t appeal to me. Great review!
Sarah recently posted..Review: Under The Never Sky by Veronica Rossi
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Kelly @ Radiant Shadows
It took me ages to decide how I felt about Incarnate, and my review is representative of my struggle – I ramble on for quite a while. I found similar issues as you, but couldn’t help but feel like I still enjoyed it because those issues didn’t seem so bad as I was reading. It was only once I started thinking about what to say about Incarnate that I really noticed its flaws.
Great review!
Kelly
Radiant Shadows
Kelly @ Radiant Shadows recently posted..In My Mailbox!
On Monday, February 13th 2012
jen
Twitter: Makeshiftjen
Agreed that the ending was abrupt, but this book was so beautiful that I didn’t care. AH, Sam. Seriously. SAM.
jen recently posted..In My Mailbox (48)
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Mari - Escape In A Book
Twitter: EscapeInABook
I’ve heard such great things about Incarnate that it was nice to read a review that was a little less glowing
If I ever buy a copy of this book my expectations won’t be too high. Have a great week reading, Kristi.
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Kris (Imaginary Reads)
Twitter: Imaginary Reads
I agree that Incarnate isn’t a huge WOW right in your face, but it’s intriguing and captivated me in its way. There are so many secrets waiting to come into the open. I’m really looking forward to where Jodi takes us next!!
Kris (Imaginary Reads) recently posted..Characters in Love Event: Character Interview with Sam
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Becky
Twitter: BeckyLeJeune
I’ve heard so many mixed things about this one. I can’t wait to jump in and find out for myself. It sounds like such an intriguing premise.
Becky recently posted..New Releases 2/14/12
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Burgandy Ice
How interesting!! I love your thoughtful review. This cover is one of my favorites and I love it when authors put a lot into their books, but I suspect I would feel just like you wrote. thx for reviewing!
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Shellie
Twitter: deviantzangel
I had the same feelings, mixed I guess. I can’t wait to see what happens in the next installment.
-Shellie
Creative Reads
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Amy @ Book Loving Mom
Twitter: amabe421
Fantastic review! I agree that I think there is a lot more that we will discover. I think that this book is a wonderful set-up to the next one. I agree with you on Sam too. I kept thinking of him as an adult, not a teenager. It was hard to imagine him as a teenage boy.
Amy @ Book Loving Mom recently posted..Review: Born Wicked by Jessica Spotswood
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Heidi
Twitter: BunburyinStacks
Sometimes I kind of enjoy not being able to decide how I feel about something. These are the things that I usually end up revisiting. Sometimes I decide I didn’t enjoy them after all, sometimes I decide I did, but it’s nice to have that wavering curiosity.
Heidi recently posted..Review: Graffiti Moon by Cath Crowley
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Birdy
I really want to read this one, it sounds interesting. Thanks for reminding me!
Birdy recently posted..Book Review: Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Dani Nosek
I’m currently in the middle of reading this and so far I love it! Can’t wait to finish it

Dani Nosek recently posted..Cinder
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Natalie Aguirre
I’ve heard mixed things about this. So I haven’t decided yet if I’ll read it. Thanks for your honest review. I appreciate it.
Natalie Aguirre recently posted..KRISTIN SIMMONS INTERVIEW AND ARTICLE 5 GIVEAWAY
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Katie @ Blook Girl
Twitter: BlookGirl
I really appreciate your review, Kristi. Very simple and candid. I know how you feel, struggling to write a review for a book that pulls you both ways. It sounds like it’s a great set-up for the next book, though
I haven’t yet read Incarnate, as I’m waiting for the local book signing next week, but I am very eager to read it.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Vyki @ On The Shelf
Twitter: whatsontheshelf
I love the cover to this one! The ending being abrupt with probably drive me nuts, but I’m going to read it anyway. Also…
You have been book tagged! Follow the link to see what it’s about and play along.
http://whatsontheshelf.wordpress.com/2012/02/14/book-tagged/
Vyki @ On The Shelf recently posted..Book Tagged!
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Shane
Twitter: embraceyoumag
I agree with your remarks because i feel the same regarding ‘the house i love’…both books have really appealing covers though
Shane recently posted..Valentine’s Day is a marketing strategy?
On Monday, February 13th 2012
Molli
Twitter: courageousgrace
Hmm, interesting! This book does seem to be a bit polarizing. Some people love it, others are on the fence, and a few people haven’t cared for it. I’m anxious to check it out for myself. I’m curious to see if I fall for Sam/Anna or if I get the same vibe and questions you did!